Political
Footnotes
by
Stuart James


Return to Current IPS Features

IPS Features

Return to Catalogue

IPS Features Staff

International Press Service

 






Political Capital or Opportunity

President Bush, last Wednesday, celebrated his victory by saying "let me put it to you this way, I earned capital in the campaign, political capital and now I intend to spend it...”

Just how much political capital did President Bush earn?  There is no doubt that the he enjoys a Republican majority in both houses of Congress.  Mr. Bush’s "political capital", however, does not come from a Republican majority.  His “political capital" comes from the number of votes he received in the election.

In this election, Mr. Bush received 59,459,765 votes.  Mr. Kerry received 55,949,407 votes.  Mr. Bush won the election by 3,510,358 votes.  Mr. Bush won the election by 34 electoral votes.  In weighing his political capital, Mr. Bush should remember he has a "political deficit” of 55,949,407 votes.  Although record numbers voted, this election is one of the closest elections in modern history.

In 2000, Mr. Bush received 50,456,016 votes.  Mr. Gore received 50,996,011 votes.  Mr. Gore won the popular vote by 539,995 votes. The electoral margin of victory was five votes with Bush receiving 271 electoral votes and Gore receiving 266 electoral votes. The 2000 election is the closest election in modern history, with Mr. Bush taking office on a razor thin electoral vote while losing the popular vote.

In weighing the amount of political capital Mr. Bush claims, it is important to keep perspective on the margin of victory, and the number of people who did not agree with Bush, as expressed in both the 2000 and 2004 elections.

In gaining a perspective on Mr. Bush’s political capital, take, for example, the following elections:

1972-Richard Nixon received 47,169,911 votes.  George McGovern received 29,170,383 votes.  Mr. Nixon received 520 electoral votes to Mr. McGovern's 17 electoral votes.

1976-Jimmy Carter received 40,830,763 votes.  Gerald R. Ford received 39,147,973 votes.  Mr. Carter received 297 electoral votes.  Mr. Ford received 240 electoral votes.  Next to the 2000 and 2004 elections, this election is one of the closest elections in modern history.  Mr. Carter's electoral margin, however, was 57 electoral votes, greater than Mr. Bush's victory in 2000 and 2004.

1980-Ronald Reagan received 43,899,248 votes.  Mr. Carter received 36,481,400 35 votes.  Mr. Reagan received 489 electoral votes.  Mr. Carter received 49 electoral votes.

1984-Ronald Reagan received 43,899,248 votes.  Walter F. Mondale received 37,577,185 votes.  Mr. Reagan received 525 electoral votes.  Mr. Mondale received 13 electoral votes.

1988-George H. Bush received 48,000,806 6097 votes.  Michael S. Dukakis received 41,809,074 votes.  Mr. Bush received 426 electoral votes.  Mr. Dukakis received 111 electoral votes.

1992-William J. Clinton received 44,909,889 votes.  George H. Bush received 39,104,545 votes.  Mr. Clinton received 370 electoral votes.  Mr. Bush received 168 electoral votes.

1996-William J. Clinton received 47,402,357 votes.  Robert J. Dole received 39,198,755 votes.  Mr. Clinton received 379 electoral votes.  Mr. Dole received 159 electoral votes.

With the exception of Mr. Carter, every president since Ronald Reagan received a greater margin of the popular vote.  Most important, the electoral margin of victory for every president since Ronald Reagan has been much more significant than either the 2000 or 2004 elections. Based upon these statistics, Mr. Bush’s political capital is thin.

Mr. Bush's political capital is best represented by his popular, and electoral, victories.  With these victories being narrow, the issue facing Bush is balance, how he can achieve balance, keeping in mind his narrow, and tenuous, victories.

The vote shows this country is deeply divided.  There are at least 55 million people who disagree with the President, expressing a lack of confidence in his leadership.  There are, on the other hand, at least 59 million people who believe in his leadership.  With this division, Mr. Bush’s challenge is not spending political capital, but building a bridge to bring this country together.

During his second term, Mr. Bush has an opportunity to:

Appoint centrist judges, judges who balance the law with the facts.  Mr. Bush should avoid appointing judges who will rule from the right or the left.  The judges Bush appoints need to achieve balance, representing the impartiality that is bedrock of our judicial system.  Judges should be appointed without regard to political affiliation or belief;

Enact meaningful reform of the justice system.  Mr. Bush must include reform of the insurance and health care industries to truly achieve tort reform.  Mr. Bush cannot simply blame the lawyers; he must take a global view of reform.

Secure Social Security for all Americans; including those currently receiving benefits and those who will receive benefits in the future. We must avoid simplistic and politically popular reform by enacting changes providing security for all who are to receive benefits under Social Security.

Reform our tax system making the system of taxation fair and equitable for all people, for all incomes; particularly helping Middle America and small businesses in achieving tax equity.  We cannot have tax equity by reforming the system for the wealthiest; we must provide meaningful relief for the middle class;

Reform his position on stem cell research, allowing stem cell research to move forward so that we can find cures for diseases such as Alzheimer's, and Parkinson's.  In moving forward in reforming his position on this research, Mr. Bush should keep Christopher Reeve, Ronald Reagan and Michael J. Fox in his mind-imagining a cure for paralysis, Alzheimer’s and Parkinson's.

Obtain a true victory in the war on terror by capturing Osama Bin Laden and destroying his terrorist network;

Heal the wounds caused by the war in Iraq;

Bring our troops home while seeking world support to maintain world security; and

Take an opportunity to govern for those 55,949,407 people who voted against him.  In a second term, Mr. Bush is free from the political shackles of the right wing.  Mr. Bush has an opportunity to lead by bridging the gap between those who voted for him and those who voted against him.  He has an opportunity to find common ground allowing all of us to move forward in a unified direction. 

During the next four years, Mr. Bush has a choice-he can do as he promised and spend the political capital he claims he earned or he can wisely govern.

We need to hope he chooses to wisely govern.

Stuart F. James
Sjames139@comcast.net